The restoration of works
by Suor Plautilla Nelli

Who was Suor Plautilla Nelli?



The Pentecost in the Church of San Domenico in Perugia

She came from a wealthy family with a street in Florence named after them. She hobnobbed with the famous painters of her day. She painted prodigiously, but only three paintings have been authenticated. Today, she remains virtually unknown. Who was she? She was a woman at a time when works of art by women were considered ‘non importanti’. She was the first known female painter of Florence when the field was dominated by men. She was a Domenican nun. She was Suor Plautilla Nelli, an artist of much note in her time, and one who is finally getting her due.

Suor Plautilla Nelli (1523-1588) was born into a noble Florentine family. She entered the convent of Santa Caterina di Siena in Florence (which taught painting and sculpting of terracotta figures) in 1538, at the age of 14, and eventually became its prioress, several times. The convent, founded by Camilla Bartolini Rucellai in 1496, was ‘run’ by the friars of San Marco, their most famous friar being Savonarola. The convent (now destroyed), located in Piazza San Marco, was supposedly annexed into the Galleria dell’Accademia in 1853 and was briefly part of the Accademia delle Belle Arti. According to noted Nelli expert, Catherine Turrill, many of the nuns at Santa Caterina were daughters of Florentine artisans and the convent was unrivaled throughout Italy for the ‘number and significance’ of its nun-artists.

Nelli’s family came from the Mugello, as did the Medici. Her father was a fabric merchant. The New Sacristy it the Church of San Lorenzo is located where the Nelli homes originally were built. Via del Canto de’ Nelli, near San Lorenzo, as named after the family and still exists today. And, Niccolo Machiavelli’s mother was Bartommea Nelli.

Suor Plautilla Nelli studied and copied works primarily by Fra’ Bartolomeo, Bronzino and Andrea del Sarto. Fra’ Bartolomeo left his drawings to his pupil, Fra Paolino, who, upon his death, left them ‘with the nun that painted,’ according to Vasari. She had many patrons (many were women) and did large alter pieces, small devotionals and miniatures, most which were lost. Nelli, with her sister, Suor Petronilla, (who wrote a biography on Savonarola, still in print), together painted several illuminations for choral books. Suor Plautilla is thought to have done the drop capitals (the large letter that begins each page), usually surrounded by a figure of a nun. A few of these exquisite illuminations, attributed to Nelli, are in the library at Museo di San Marco and the Biblioteca Marucelliana, not on public display.

The Lamentation with Saints in the Refectory of San Marco Museum is her most famous public work, which expresses a rare raw emotional grief of Christ’s death, depicted through the red eyes and visible tears of the figures. Her Last Supper originally hung in the refectory of her convent, but, since 1853, it is in the Refectory of Santa Maria Novella, not open to the public and in dire need of restoration. The Pentecost in the Church of San Domenico in Perugia is another of her recognized works. Several experts have also attributed The Madonna and Child with St. Catherine and Two Angels (Lo Sposalizio Mistico di Santa Caterina) in the Galleria Collegiata in Empoli. Since the restoration of Lamentation with Saints 14 other works by Suor Plautilla Nelli have been authenticated since 2008 (see Segment ‘Rediscovering Nelli’).

According to Catherine Turrill, Nelli was probably buried inside her convent of Santa Caterina di Siena, in a general tomb with the other prioresses of the convent. But neither the convent, nor the church connected to it, exists today. The structures were replaced by the Tosco-Emilian Regional Military Command, so another question is what actually happened to the burial site after the convent was closed in the early 19th century, to be eventually demolished and built over.

Florence—so well-known for its Renaissance art—has overlooked Nelli, its first acknowledged woman painter, as has most of the art world. Why? Perhaps, it is because she did not have the advantage of studying. Or it could be that, because of her profession, she represented all her figures with female characteristics, and was thus, initially not given her proper due.

Text taken from the article: ‘Prayer for the painter: Sister Nelli gets her due’, by Jane Fortune, originally published in The Florentine (Issue no. 42/ October 2006)